I ordered the Peanut Nutter Butter, Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup, Brownie Batter and Blueberry Pastry flavors for the first time. I love them all, but the Peanut Nutter Butter and Chocolate Peanit Butter Cup are my favorites. Mixing them with Fage 0% and with Jordan’s Skinny Mix Surups are my favorite combinations so far.